LAWYERS SAY NUCLEAR SUBSIDIES MAY BE UNLAWFUL
Lawyers working with the campaigning group Energy Fair say that some existing and proposed new subsidies for nuclear power in the UK may be unlawful under EU laws designed to promote fair competition between businesses.
A formal complaint about those subsidies is now being prepared for submission to the European Commission.
Research by Energy Fair has shown that there are 11 existing or proposed new subsidies for the nuclear industry. Withdrawal of any one of them, via legal or political action, is likely to make new nuclear power plants uncompetitive.
“Our research is in line with what others have been saying” says Dr Gerry Wolff, Coordinator of the Energy Fair group. “MPs have already raised concerns about provisions in the recent Finance Act that will produce windfall profits for the nuclear industry. The Government itself says that the industry will benefit by £50 million per year, and calculations by WWF and Greenpeace show that the subsidy could be as much as £3.43 billion between 2013 and 2026”.
1 Contact: Dr Gerry Wolff PhD CEng, Coordinator, Energy Fair, firstname.lastname@example.org, +44 (0) 1248 712962, +44 (0) 7746 290775, www.energyfair.org.uk, 18 Penlon, Menai Bridge, Anglesey, LL59 5LR, UK.
2 Lawyer Dr Dörte Fouquet, with a lawyer colleague, is working with the Energy Fair group in preparing a formal complaint to the European Commission. She is senior partner in the law firm BBH (www.beckerbuettnerheld.de/en/) and Director of the European Renewable Energies Federation (EREF, www.eref-europe.org/).
3 The proposed action by Energy Fair, to make a formal complaint to the European Commission about subsidies for nuclear power, is endorsed by the following people and organisations: Tom Burke CBE, Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament, Eurosolar, Jean Lambert MEP, Caroline Lucas MP, Nuclear Free Local Authorities, Michael Meacher MP, People Against Wylfa B (PAWB), Jonathon Porritt CBE, Solarcentury, Sortir du Nucléaire, Keith Taylor MEP, and Urgewald.
4 Reports about MPs’ concerns about subsidies for nuclear power include:
- “Lib Dem MPs set to rebel against nuclear power 'subsidy'” (The Guardian, 2011-07-01, www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2011/jul/01/lib-dem-rebel-nuclear-power-subsidy).
- “MPs attack government's covert subsidies for nuclear industry” (The Guardian, 2011-05-16, www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2011/may/16/nuclear-energy-industry-select-committee).
- “UK breaks promise on nuclear power subsidies, say MPs” (BBC News, 2011-05-16, www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-13393732).
5 Research by the Energy Fair group has identified 11 existing or proposed subsidies for nuclear power. They are summarised in “Forms of support for nuclear power” (PDF, www.mng.org.uk/ns) and described more fully in the following two documents:
- “Subsidies for nuclear power in the UK government’s proposals for electricity market reform” (PDF, www.mng.org.uk/emrdoc).
- “Nuclear Subsidies” (PDF, www.mng.org.uk/nsubsidies).
6 With regard to the ‘carbon price floor’ (now part of the Finance Act 2011):
- In Parliament, the then Economic Secretary, Justine Greening MP, said on the 9th of May 2011: “The existing nuclear sector is likely to benefit by an average of £50 million per annum to 2030 due to higher wholesale electricity prices.”
- According to calculations by WWF and Greenpeace, the measure could result in windfall profits for existing nuclear generators of up to £3.43 billion between 2013 and 2026 (“Energy bills to rise as nuclear gets £3.43 billion for doing nothing”, WWF press release, 2011-02-14, www.wwf.org.uk/what_we_do/press_centre/?4629/Energy-bills-to-rise-as-nuclear-gets-343bn-for-doing-nothing).